No matter how well-prepared you are, the days and hours leading up to a big performance, audition, or heck, even an important recording, can be an emotional roller coaster.
One minute you’re feeling like your normal self. But then, zing! Suddenly you get a jolt of adrenaline, and a fluttering of butterflies in your tummy reminds you that the countdown has begun!
As the moment draws nearer, it can be easy to start questioning your preparation and worry about whether it’s going to be one of those good days or bad days. Your brain may start providing you with a whole series of what-if scenarios and reminders of worst-case scenarios from your past. Which can get those butterflies all riled up, trigger an anxiety spiral, and make you begin to feel a little panicky.
This is not a very fun way to spend your time backstage, of course. And often, there’s a tendency for all of this to spill over into our experience on stage too, resulting in a subpar level of playing that doesn’t really represent what we’re capable of.
So how can we interrupt this cycle and set ourselves up for a more successful performance?
What do elite performers do?
Anecdotally, a lot of elite athletes and musicians describe using imagery at times like this to get into a more positive headspace.
Specifically, they will visualize and try to emotionally re-experience previous positive performances. Like a personal highlight reel of best moments from one’s past, to help crowd out the lowlight reel and what-if’s that could sabotage their performance.
Interesting…but can this kind of positive thinking really have a meaningful impact on our nerves, and ultimately the quality of our playing under pressure?
A study!
To find out, a team of researchers (Watanabe et al., 2025) recruited 36 professional musicians between the ages of 24 and 60, with anywhere from 3 to 38 years of professional performing experience.
Participants came to a soundproof recording studio and had electrodes placed on their chest so that the researchers could collect electrocardiogram (ECG) data and monitor heart rate and rhythm.
They sat quietly first for five minutes to establish a baseline of their heart rate. And then they stood for five minutes to get their baseline ECG data in that position.
Next, they were asked to spend five minutes engaging in some mental imagery of each of three different scenarios.
Three visualization scenarios
One time, they were asked to vividly recall a particular performance where they experienced their “most positive emotional state” (positive condition).
Another time, they were asked to visualize a performance where they experienced their “most negative emotional state” (negative condition).
And a third time, they were asked to imagine waiting backstage, as if they were getting ready to perform (control condition).
In each scenario, they were asked to recall as many of the details of the experience as possible, using all of their senses. Like the sound of the music, their breathing, muscle tension, and how playing felt that day. The idea being to try to relive the experience, rather than simplly describing it in an intellectual sort of way.
Then a recording with some pressure
Then, finally, they performed the prepared piece for a recording device. To add a tiny bit of pressure, the researchers let the musicians know that their recordings would be evaluated by the other musicians in the study. 😁
The musicians were also asked to rate their own performances after each recording on a 1-9 scale, where 1=did not perform to their potential at all, and 9=performed to their potential extremely well. And they also completed a quick “Affect Grid” assessment, where they were able to pinpoint their emotional state. As in, how positive or negative they felt while performing, and also how physically amped up or calm they were.
So…did the different imagery scripts lead to any differences in the quality of the musicians’ performances, or in their physical response to having to do some recording under a bit of pressure?
Results
Well, in terms of the quality of their performances, the musicians gave their performances in the positive imagery condition an average score of 6.06 out of 9. Compared to an average of 5.03 in the negative condition and a 5.81 in the control condition.
The musicians were a little more physiologically activated in the positive condition as well, with an activation score of 6.06. Compared to 4.89 for the negative condition and 5.28 for the control condition.
But at the same time, the musicians seemed to be in a more positive emotional state as well in the positive condition, with an average emotional valence score of 6.31. Compared to a lowly 3.78 for the negative condition and 5.47 for the control condition.
There was no statistically significant difference between the musicians’ performance quality ratings of each others’ playing. But the researchers note that the musicians actually didn’t listen to very much of each others’ recordings – just the first 20 seconds of each condition, which amounts to about 6-7 notes.
And sure, you can often tell quite a bit about a player from the first 6-7 notes, but the selected piece was also not a very challenging or demanding piece, especially for professional musicians, so it’s likely that there wasn’t much for the musicians to go off of, and they could easily have given relatively similar scores across the board. That said, there was a correlation between their self-ratings and the ratings of the other musicians, so it does seem that the improvements in their playing were noticeable to the listeners to some degree.
So what are we to make of all of this?
Takeaways
Well, there are more details in the study that there isn’t room to include here, but all in all, the findings suggest that the goal for optimizing performance is not a state of complete zen-like calm and relaxation.
It seems that we should actually aim to get into a more physically activated state – but pair that with positive, rather than negative emotions.
In other words, to take those butterflies and combine them with positive memories or images, so that it all feels a little more like excitement than anxiety/fear/panic.
Which is a finding that aligns with much of the research in sport psychology and other related fields.
So how do we do this?
Take action
Well, the obvious and overly simplistic answer is to just do it. Like, when your brain tempts you to dwell on a range of past performance or audition fails, and worst-case scenarios and what-if’s, don’t go there! Spend your time backstage visualizing positive past performances instead.
Of course, that’s way easier said than done! Especially if you haven’t prepared yourself for this.
So I think the more sneakily important action step is to a) prepare a highlight reel or select a specific positive performance experience in advance, and then b) practice visualizing the various details of this this memory regularly, before studio classes, gigs, small performances, recordings, and so on. Otherwise, under pressure, it may be difficult to recall all the important vidid details – or even the core memory itself – when you need it most!
More tips on managing nerves?
Managing and overcoming nerves and performance anxiety is one of the core skills we’re going to focus on in the live 4-week Performance Psych Essentials class that begins in a couple weeks. We’ll also work on effective practice, performing confidently, and focus under pressure, fwiw, as those are all related too! Registration begins next week (Sept. 21-28, 2025) if you’d like to join in!
Join the waitlist for Cohort 25
References
Watanabe, A., Kondoh, S., Samma, T., & Fujii, S. (2025). Enhanced subjective performance achievement in wind instrument playing through positive memory recall: effects of sympathetic activation and emotional valence. Frontiers in Psychology, 16. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1544069


