Legendary basketball coach John Wooden often urged his players to “be quick – but don’t hurry.”
Indeed, whether it’s a buzzer-beating three pointer or a tricky shift in Don Juan there’s something about rushing that messes with the execution of motor skills. The timing and rhythm of our movements get off, fluidity and ease go out the window, and we force things instead of letting them happen.
Ok…but how exactly are we supposed to avoid rushing shifts, hurrying through tricky passages, and compressing rests under pressure?
Well, there are a number of things we can do to be a little more centered in moments like this of course. But one important strategy begins well before we walk on stage.
The rushing domino effect
Olympic diving coach Jeff Huber once said that the tendency to rush doesn’t just happen suddenly at the moment of execution. And that it can actually creep into your day well before the competition begins – from the moment you wake up and feel those butterflies fluttering in your stomach.
Because if you wake up in a hurry, shower in a hurry, eat breakfast and get changed in a hurry, and go from the hotel to the pool in a hurry, there will be a tendency to rush through warmups too, “with tense muscles, stiff movements, and taut facial expressions.” Which can ultimately lead to rushing your dives during the actual competition as well.
So how can we get ourselves to slow down more generally on performance or audition days? Is there anything in the research about this?
I thought it might be fun to take a look at a few studies related to this. The first couple studies might initially seem a little tangential, but I think you’ll find that it all comes together in the end. 😁
The role of Muzak?
We often don’t even notice, but most stores and restaurants have music playing in the background. The theory was that this would put us in a better mood and get us to buy more stuff. However, for years, nobody actually tested this premise; it was simply assumed.
Then Ronald Milliman came along and did a study to see if music could actually affect the behavior of real shoppers at a grocery store (Milliman, 1982).
For 9 weeks, they systematically changed the background music in a medium-sized grocery store located in the southwestern US. On a third of the days, they played no music at all. On another third, they played slow music (defined as music 72bpm or slower). And on the other days, they played fast music (94bpm or faster).
And did that change anything?
Walking speed?
Milliman was curious about two things. Would the music change how quickly or slowly shoppers walked through the store? And would this affect sales in some way?
By measuring the time it took for customers to pass between designated points in the store, Milliman found that on no-music days, customers would pass between the designated points in 119.86 seconds.
On slow-music days, it would take them 127.53 seconds (~8 seconds slower).
And on fast-music days, they’d pass between the points in only 108.93 seconds (~11 seconds faster).
The 8-11 second difference between no-music and slow music or no-music and fast music wasn’t statistically significant, but the ~19 second difference between slow-music and fast-music days absolutely was.
Which in turn seemed to have a significant impact on sales.
Sales?
On the fast-music days, when customers were zipping through the store, average sales was $12,112.85.
And on slow-music days when shoppers were moseying their way around (and presumably took more time to notice other things they needed or wanted), average sales jumped to $16,740.23.
So there was a 38% increase in sales, just by changing the tempo of the music, and influencing the pace of their movements!
What about restaurants?
A few years later, Milliman tried this experiment in a restaurant setting (Milliman, 1986). Since restaurants can serve more customers if diners finish their meals faster, he was curious to see how the tempo of background music might affect dining speed.
Would they stay longer, with slow background music? And leave sooner, with fast music?
Dining speed
Turns out, yes!
When slow music was playing, an average of 56 minutes elapsed from the time a party was seated, to the time they left. When fast music was playing, that number dropped to 45 minutes.
So Milliman’s studies suggest that background music can have a significant effect on the speed of our movements, largely out of conscious awareness.
But can music affect our emotional state as well?
Pre-surgery anxiety
More recently, a team of Taiwanese researchers did a study to see what sort of effect music would have on the anxiety of 161 patients who were about to undergo surgery (Lee et al., 2011).
About 30 minutes before surgery was to begin, each patient was escorted into a waiting room, given a quick anxiety assessment, and hooked up to a heart rate monitor.
Ten minutes into their wait, about half of the patients were given an MP3 player, headphones, and a selection of music to choose from (the music group). All musical selections were “light” folk or pop in the 60-80bpm range.
The other half of the patients simply continued to sit and wait (the quiet rest group).
After 10 minutes of listening (or sitting quietly), participants retook the anxiety assessment, and had their heart rate checked once again.
So did listening to music have any effect on anxiety or heart rate?
Music’s impact
As you probably already guessed, listening to music did have a soothing effect on patients’ anxiety. Their anxiety dropped from an average of 3.5 (where 0=calm, 10=very anxious) to 2.8.
Regarding heart rate, while the quiet rest group’s heart rate stayed the same throughout the waiting period, the music group’s heart rate actually slowed down.
So what can we take away from all of this?
Takeaways
The idea of using music to help manage anxiety about an upcoming music performance might seem a little ironic. 😆
But athletes have used music to calm down or get pumped up on game day for ages, and it seems that we too could better regulate our internal state by adding the right background music to our concert or audition day playlist.
So try putting together a soundtrack of slower bpm music for the morning of performances, for instance. Music that helps you settle into a slower rhythm for the day. Or that helps you get recentered during those moments backstage when you start to get a little too revved up.
And don’t forget to prepare a separate playlist of higher-bpm music too, for those times when you might be feeling a little too relaxed or lethargic! Tunes that help you get amped up and excited, so you can go on stage feeling more confident and energized!
Additional stuff
If you find yourself overthinking the selection of music for your playlist, and want to try a more nature-y approach, learn how birdsong could help to enhance calm:
And if you’re looking to procrastinate for a bit longer today, the idea for this post came from a podcast episode on why it is that there seems to be music everywhere…except public restrooms. Check that out here:
- Time to Take Back the Toilet @Freakonomics Radio
References
Lee K-C, Chao Y-H, Yiin J-J, Hsieh H-Y, Dai W-J, Chao Y-F. Evidence That Music Listening Reduces Preoperative Patients’ Anxiety. Biological Research For Nursing. 2012;14(1):78-84. doi:10.1177/1099800410396704
Milliman, R. E. (1982). Using Background Music to Affect the Behavior of Supermarket Shoppers. Journal of Marketing, 46(3), 86-91. https://doi.org/10.1177/002224298204600313
Milliman, R. E. (1986). The Influence of Background Music on the Behavior of Restaurant Patrons. Journal of Consumer Research, 13(2), 286–289. http://www.jstor.org/stable/2489234



Hi Dr. Kageyama,
Thanks for the post and for bringing these studies together. Is there research on how other features of the music affect might make a difference? I’m asking because it’s intuitively a bad idea to play a recording of the part of a slow piece from which comes an excerpt for your audition if the recording does something contrary to the way you prepared it. Or maybe it’s better not to listen to your own pieces at all…or is the opposite true? Is it better to stay away from classical music altogether, or perhaps anything other than the styles we’re about to play? (just to provide an example of what I mean by “other features”)
Best,
Elliot
Hi Elliot,
I haven’t looked into it, but I suspect there is other research out there on the impact of other features of music on behavior/mood (like volume, for instance).
As far as whether to listen to recordings of excerpts or not, I think it depends on the timing. For me, excerpts are probably not the way I’d want to start the morning, and I may not want to spend most of the day hearing the same excerpts over and over either. There may be a specific window of time when you’d want to listen to excerpts, or the full orchestral part of that section, or maybe even your own best takes of the excerpt. But during the rest of the day it may be best to use music as a tool to help you regulate your mood or energy, whether that means listening to other classical rep you like, and reminds you of why you wanted to be a musician in the first place, or rock/jazz/pop/etc. that you enjoy.
Hi Dr. Kageyama,
Firstly thanks for sharing all this research and tips on how to perform and practice more awesome with everyone!
Have you ever done a podcast/blog on how to deal with seeing a musician friend struggling with a mental block/problem? Both on how to help them, but also how to not get distracted by it yourself?
Also it would be cool if you could share ways of how to become a mental health coach for musicians?
All the best!
Ariadna
Hi Ariadna,
Good question! I think sometimes, the most helpful thing we can do, rather than trying to “fix” things for them or give them advice, is to listen to our friends, give them a chance to verbalize their frustrations or challenges if they want to talk about it, and let them know that they’re not alone, and that what they’re experiencing isn’t as unusual as it might feel. That we’ve all been there in some form or fashion, and that it’s something we can overcome and learn to get better at.
Regarding more formal training to help musicians on the mental side of things, there are a number of different pathways, but depending on what sort of work you’d like to do, a master’s in counseling or performance psychology is a pretty common route, and one you can often pursue even if your undergraduate degree is/was in music. You might find clarinetist Jason Shafer’s podcast episode to be of interest, as this is something he did recently: Jason Shafer: On Healthier Practicing & Strengths-Based Performing