The Hidden Cost of Avoiding Failure

Whether it involved playing softball at recess, shoveling the driveway, or dealing with mosquitoes and diarrhea, “building character” was one of the recurring themes in the comic strip Calvin and Hobbes.

Character-building is not particularly fun, but was Calvin’s dad onto something?

Is there something about those painful, miserable experiences that makes us stronger? Or does it just undermine our confidence?


I recently read an interesting Slate article written by a staff counselor at the NYU student health center, in which she observes that many college and graduate students seem to have under-developed emotional intelligence skills like conflict resolution, dealing with frustration and ambiguity, and independent decision-making. All the kinds of skills that tend to be developed through difficult, uncertain, and trying “character-building” situations that we would all prefer to avoid.

As a parent, it makes me wonder if in trying to minimize our kids’ struggles, we step in too quickly with answers or assistance and deprive them of an important opportunity to struggle, flounder, fail…and ultimately build character?

And what message does it send our kids, when we intervene before they’ve had a chance to fail, experiment, and find their own way?

The implicit message is that we don’t believe they are up to the task. And that it’s more important to get it right and avoid mistakes than to make a mess of things, even if they finally do figure things out.

But think about the times when you’ve felt best about yourself. Hasn’t it been when you’ve struggled with something difficult, and could only put all the pieces together after stretching your wits, physical capacity, and frustration tolerance to the limit?

That hard-fought independent victory can be a huge confidence booster, and an important building block of mental toughness.

The tricky thing of course, is that there are two ways we can fail. Fail the right way, and we are better off. Fail the wrong way, and we could be worse off.

How to succeed at failing

When we receive information that suggests we could have done something better than we did (a.k.a. failure), there’s a part of us that kicks into damage-control mode and tries to protect our sense of self. That way we can still feel like we are a good person, a good musician, and a worthwhile human being.

We tend to handle the failure data in one of a few different ways.

1. Ignore, minimize, or dismiss the data

As in, “That critic is totally biased against people from school XYZ” or “They aren’t asking me to play because they feel threatened.”

Sure, the “it’s not me, it’s you” strategy might help us protect our ego. And it might even be true sometimes. But this is not the ideal long-term performance strategy, because we’re not going to get any better if we remain in defensive mode and can’t acknowledge the things that could be improved.

2. Acknowledge the data; attribute it to personal deficiencies

As in, “I’m not a strong technical player” or “I’m a bad sight reader” or “I’m horrible at math” or “I’m not good with faces” or “I don’t think I’m relationship material”

In a roundabout sort of way, this strategy sort of protects our ego, in that we will tend to avoid specific situations where we could “fail” again. But in the long run, it just makes things even worse. Not only does it still feel crappy and make us feel worse about ourselves overall, but it totally closes the door on improving the thing we think is unchangeable.

If we keep attributing failures to an innate lack of ability, we limit our ability to grow, learn, and develop, and stunt our performance potential in all sorts of areas where we might actually be quite able – just slow to pick up on things at the outset.

3. Acknowledge the data; attribute it to the failing of a specific strategy

As in, “Wow, I really didn’t handle that situation as well as I could have. Next time maybe I will try doing x, y, or z.”

Or “Yikes, that passage rushed and sounded really uneven. Next time I could try thinking about _____. Or maybe I could do more work on rhythms. Or more recording, so I notice that stuff in advance. Or schedule more run-throughs in front of people, so I can practice dealing with nerves.”

Embrace your FOGs

When I was doing my psychology internship the staff would send us challenging clients, crises, and training sessions as “opportunities for growth.” We came to refer to them good-naturedly as “FOG’s” (I’ll let you guess what the “F” stood for), but embraced them anyway because we knew they were unavoidable, and would ultimately help us become better at the work we do.

We will all encounter FOGs in life whether we want to or not, so we might as well use them to our advantage. To really lean into the FOGs and use them as a rare opportunity to dig down deep and strengthen our resolve, our skills, and mental toughness.

Because while it might be impressive to watch your favorite NBA team cruise through an entire season full of easy wins, when they encounter a tough opponent who has faced adversity, you may find that failure has better prepared the underdogs to pull out a victory, because they’ve learned how to hang tough and deal with difficult times.

They have learned from hard-fought experience that they can miss shots, or get down by 20 points, and still have what it takes to come back and win, because they’ve done it before, and have learned how to focus not on their missed shots or missed plays, but on devising more effective strategies and gameplans – which can always be tweaked and improved.

In the words of Helen Keller, “Character cannot be developed in ease and quiet. Only through experience of trial and suffering can the soul be strengthened, ambition inspired, and success achieved.”

photo credit: .robbie via photopin cc

Ack! After Countless Hours of Practice...
Why Are Performances Still So Hit or Miss?

It’s not a talent issue. And that rush of adrenaline and emotional roller coaster you experience before performances is totally normal too.

Performing at the upper ranges of your ability under pressure is a unique skill – one that requires specific mental skills, and perhaps a few other tweaks in your approach to practicing too. Elite athletes have been learning these techniques for decades; if nerves and self-doubt have been recurring obstacles in your performances, I’d like to help you do the same.

Click below to learn more about Beyond Practicing – a home-study course where you’ll explore the 6 skills that are characteristic of top performers. And learn how you can develop these into strengths of your own. And begin to see tangible improvements in your playing that transfer to the stage.


5 Responses

  1. Wow! This is important stuff! Strategy two reminds me of Carol Dwek’s “Mindset” and how we approach our failures (and successes). Thanks, Noa!

  2. The idea of failure is perceived, and therefore variable, if not malleable. It’s difficult not to feel various degrees of failure when we have worked so hard, and ‘failed’ to accomplish a defined goal. For seemingly most people failure are perceived as a negative; by definition and the perception of one’s peers. It’s one thing to feel that we have failed to achieve a particular objective and cannot rise above this perception, and quite another thing to feel that we have failed, yet continually strive to ‘succeed’ because we perceive failure as a bump in the road; temporally disorienting our efforts. Sometimes failure, as in competition, is a matter of personal taste, and has little to do with objective assessments of technical or artistic ability. Failure can be a powerful motivator, as so much of the history of human accomplishment demonstrates. But failure as an attitude is potentially destructive, specifically if we cannot eventually rise above it. For me, given a respectable grounding, (training), great instructors, and a genuinely stimulating environment consisting of devoted fellow student, acceptable instruments to practice and perform upon; what is often lacking is certain ancillary training; mental training or reframing, yes, tailored individually. I’m no expert but believe that certain cultures do a better job of accomplishing this task. There are ‘exercises’ that can be integrated into a program of musical study that is absolutely necessary for some students in order to, in general, enhance practice/performance; specifically enlightened drills, guided and personal meditations, visualization exercises, even aerobic exercises. These efforts have the potential to, when needful, to not only minimize certain kinds of so-called failures, but to reframe our sense of what constitutes failure. The martial artist Bruce Lee created a revolution by integrating physical training, (ancillary training), to a much higher degree than was typical at the time into his martial arts training. What he accomplished was legendary, and today this mode of practice is standard, especially among the best martial artist. In summary, the idea of failure can be reframed, and thus ‘balanced’ by achieving a level of practice, at and away from ones instrument, that targets the aforementioned skills, tailored to the individual student.

  3. This is a really great post, and timely for me since I just finished the Heath brothers book Switch, about how to make change happen. One of the biggest points to remember there, is in motivating yourself or others to change, is to make sure that you have the 3rd mindset when it comes to failure above.

    If it was simply the circumstances, your plan, or even luck that caused a failure, you’re much more likely to make the adjustments in order to succeed. If you fail because that’s the type of person you are, well that’s a long road.

    I also like the FOG acronym. 🙂 I’ll have to steal that one.

  4. Pingback: Failure | Fearless

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Get the (Free) Practice Hacks Guide

Learn the #1 thing that top practicers do differently, plus 7 other strategies for practice that sticks.

Discover your mental strengths and weaknesses

If performances have been frustratingly inconsistent, try the 3-min Mental Skills Audit. It won't tell you what Harry Potter character you are, but it will point you in the direction of some new practice methods that could help you level up in the practice room and on stage.