Have you ever had a really rough day (or month), turned to perusing your friends’ Facebook status updates, and moments later, been filled with feelings of gratitude and appreciation for how great your life is?
Meh…probably not so much.
It’s easy to forget that what we see on Facebook is not a complete picture of our friends’ lives, but mostly just the cool bits. So even though we are happy for them, it can still trigger a twinge or two of envy to see everyone’s shiny new jobs, relationships, and ramen burgers while we sit alone on our couch, reflecting on an unsuccessful audition, eating instant cup ramen.
No wonder why much has been made of “Facebook depression.” (And check out this amusing, but incisive short film )
But is Facebook really all that bad for us? Or might there be something positive in there somewhere, that could prove beneficial to the development of our lives and careers?
Is Facebook depression real?
A recent study suggests that Facebook itself is not the problem. That on its own, Facebook can be a perfectly healthy diversion and a fun way to stay connected to friends and family. The problem is when we start spending too much time on Facebook, using it as a social comparison tool – a way to gauge how well we are doing relative to others. Deliberately or not, when we are confronted with pictures, videos, and other indicators of others’ seemingly perfect lives and cats, it can lead to feelings of envy, which can in turn lead to feelings of depression.
Two sides of envy
Envy sounds like one of those negative emotions that slowly eats away at our soul and turns us into bitter, empty, self-loathing shells of our former selves – but wait! Envy may not always be bad.
Because there are two kinds of envy – a productive type (benign envy) in addition to the more familiar destructive variety (malicious envy).
Benign envy tends to be associated with actions that are centered around self-improvement, while malicious envy tends to be associated with actions geared towards tearing others down. Fittingly, we are more likely to experience benign envy when we see someone experience success that we feel is well-deserved. If we think someone’s success is undeserved, we are more likely to experience malicious envy.
Ok…so rebranding envy with a kinder, gentler name is interesting, but envy of any kind still comes with some emotional pain, which can’t be great, right?
What about admiration, for instance? That’s usually regarded as a much healthier and noble emotion than envy. And it’s supposed to be a powerful force that can inspire and motivate us to work harder and do better, right?
Researchers in the Netherlands decided to put admiration and the two types of envy to a 3-way deathmatch, and set up a series of studies to see which would come out on top.
Study #1: Motivation
The first study was simply designed to see if benign envy would lead to greater motivation to improve one’s grades than malicious envy or admiration.
Seventeen undergraduate students were asked to describe someone they knew well who was better at something than they were. Then, they rated how benignly envious, maliciously envious, or admiring they were of this person on a scale of 1 (not at all) to 7 (very much so).
Later, in what they were led to believe was a separate study, the students had to respond to the following question: “Compared to last semester, how many hours more or less do you plan to spend on your study in the upcoming semester?”
Only benign envy was related to an increase in the number of hours students planned on studying.
Benign envy with the early lead! 1-0-0
Study #2: Performance
In the next study, the researchers wanted to kick things up a notch and see if benign envy would lead to an actual change in behavior.
They took 86 participants and randomly assigned them to a benign envy group, malicious envy group, admiration group, and control group. Each was asked to recall an experience of benign envy, malicious envy, admiration, or nothing (for the control group), and then rate how positive or negative the memory felt (-3 for very negative to +3 for very positive).
A short time later, in the context of what they were led to believe was a different and unrelated study, they completed an 18-item test which was introduced to them as “an important instrument used to measure creativity and leadership.”
The admiration group felt much more positively towards the person in their recalled experience (1.82) than the benign envy (-.86) or malicious envy (-1.24) group. However, the benign envy group outperformed the other groups with an average score of 11.38 (out of 18) vs. 9.82 for the admiration group, 8.48 for the malicious envy group, and 9.33 for the control group.
Two in a row! Benign envy 2-0-0
Study #3: Persistence
The third study took the second study a step further, and found that participants in the benign envy group not only scored higher, but persisted longer in the task than those in the other groups. And even if you controlled for how much longer they spent on the task, they still scored higher than those in the other groups.
A shutout in the making. Benign envy 3-0-0…
Study #4: Growth vs. Fixed Mindset
The final study may be the most intriguing in some ways. Half of the participants were primed with the idea that change and improvement is easy (growth mindset), while the other half were primed with the idea that change is hard (fixed mindset). (Here’s a great read on the growth vs. fixed mindset, if this sounds unfamiliar)
Then, they read a newspaper article on a fictitious model student who performed well in a student competition, and were asked how much benign envy, malicious envy, or admiration they felt towards him.
Then, they were asked how much extra time they planned on studying in the upcoming semester.
The results suggest that when we have a growth mindset and come across someone who is more successful than us, we are more likely to experience benign envy than admiration (which then leads to greater motivation to do the work). If, on the other hand, we have a fixed mindset and believe that improvement is not possible, we are more likely to feel admiration and not experience greater motivation to do the work.
So why did envy trump admiration?
The authors quote the philosopher Kierkegaard, who once said that “Admiration is happy self-surrender; envy is unhappy self-assertion,” and suggest that while admiration feels more positive, the twinge of emotional pain that comes with benign envy, paired with the belief that we are capable of making changes makes us more likely to take action and work towards a brighter future.
So next time you feel a twinge of envy, don’t beat yourself up for feeling that way. It may not be the the most pleasant emotion, but if it’s of the benign variety, use it! Leverage that motivation to do the work and take a step forward.
The original paper is worth reading – there are some interesting nuances and things to consider in the discussion section. (Click here to download)
For more on growth vs. fixed mindsets, take the online mindset test, and check out the book.
photo credit: Jealousy via photopin (license)