Charismatic, Inspiring Performers – What’s Their Secret?

Dancers elicit emotions through movement.

Writers do the same through their use of words.

As musicians, we speak to our audiences through sound. Where though artful manipulation of melody, harmony, rhythm, dynamics, articulation, and more, we can elicit an emotional experience in our listeners that they may not otherwise encounter on an average day.

But in spending so much time and attention on honing our skill in shaping and crafting the sounds we use to communicate, it can be easy to forget that we also have the ability to communicate with our audience in other ways. That what our listeners see has a significant impact on their experience of our performance too (as in this and this).

Perhaps you’ve had the experience of watching a competition like the Cliburn, where some performers have inspired and moved you, while others haven’t? Where the level of playing was all extremely high, but one performer’s charisma and stage presence added something more to your experience?

How does one do this? Can we all become more charismatic and inspiring – and give the kind of performance that elicits an emotional response that our audience remembers for days, weeks, or a lifetime afterwards?

Charisma…and sleep?

Previous research has suggested that one of the main ingredients in charisma is one’s ability to embody and display positive emotions (e.g. enthusiasm, gravitas) depending on what the situation demands. Knowing this, a team of researchers wanted to explore this further – by throwing sleep deprivation into the mix.

I know – that sounds totally random. Why sleep deprivation?

Well, others have made a connection between sleep and emotion regulation. So if positive emotions play a central role in charisma, maybe sleep is an underrated, but critical factor in the charisma equation?

Yeah…still seems random, but let’s take a closer look, shall we?

A commencement address

88 business students were recruited to participate in this study, asked to prepare an inspiring commencement address, and deliver it on camera.

But the night before, half of these students were given a task designed to ensure a poor night’s sleep1, while the other half were allowed to sleep as they normally would.

Inspiring? Or not?

Three judges then viewed all of the speeches, and rated each of the speakers on measures of charismatic leadership. None of the judges knew that some speakers had slept poorly the night before, or what the purpose of the study was – only that these were students asked to deliver a commencement address as student body leader.

Nevertheless, the participants in the sleep-deprived group were consistently rated as being less charismatic than those who got a good night’s sleep.

That may not be so surprising in and of itself, but what is a bit more fascinating is why being sleep deprived affected their charisma and ability to inspire.

Deep acting

The researchers asked the participants a variety of questions both before and after their speech, ranging from how they felt before giving the speech (e.g. Enthusiastic? Excited? Attentive?) to the degree to which they were able to act out the emotions they wanted to convey in their speech (e.g. Did they actually experience the emotions they wanted to show? Or just faked it?).

I would have guessed that being tired affected the speakers’ mood or emotional state, which in turn led to a less inspiring speech. But that’s not quite how it worked out; the sleep deprived participants’ pre-speech emotional states weren’t much different than those who were well-rested.

What was different, was their “deep acting” ability – the capacity to reach within, authentically feel the emotions they hoped to convey to their audience, and speak directly from that place.

The sleep deprived speakers felt that their ability in this area was compromised. And the worse they felt about their deep acting, the less and less charismatic their speeches became.

But wait, there’s more!

Ok, but what about those times when you feel like you’re giving everything you have, and the audience still doesn’t seem to respond?

The researchers were curious about this too, and ran a second study to see what role sleep deprivation has on the audience.

They selected three videos from the previous study, representing various levels of charisma – ranging from one of the more uninspiring speakers to one of the most charismatic speakers, as well as one in the average range – and had well-rested and sleep-deprived students watch and rate these speakers on their charisma.

Not inspired

As you can probably guess, the observers who were sleep-deprived found the speakers to be less charismatic than the observers who had gotten a good night of sleep.

Here too the question of “why” is probably more interesting than the result itself. So why were sleep-deprived participants less inspired by the same speeches?

The answer had to do with emotions, but it played out in a slightly different way than in the first study.

You know how when you’re tired, you tend to be cranky and in a less positive mood? Apparently, being in a crappy mood affects our perceptions of charisma too. Where, like Jabba the Hut, we just aren’t as susceptible to charismatic folks’ Jedi mind powers.

3 takeaways

Takeaway #1: Sleep!

It seems that we have in this study yet another reason to make sleep a priority – and not just the night before, but in general. That way, we can avoid putting too much pressure on that one night of sleep, when we’ve been accumulating a sleep debt all along.

Takeaway #2: Deep acting?

This notion of deep acting is intriguing, and I imagine it plays a role in charisma in music performance too. It’s not something I ever did intentionally, but have you ever sought to engage in “deep acting” as a way of adding to the audience’s experience of your music? Though it’s important to note here that simply “feeling the music” is no guarantee that we are playing in a way that actually engenders an emotional experience in our listener – and in some cases can lead to our feeling inspired, but our audience not so much (as violinist Pam Frank explains here ; and as cellist Frans Helmerson once spoke of).

Takeaway #3: Don’t take the audience reaction personally

It doesn’t matter how well-prepared you are, how beautiful your sound is, how interesting your ideas are, or how cool your shirt is.

A notable portion of your audience just won’t find you as charismatic, inspiring, and moving as others will. So don’t let that get to you. Especially if you catch a few of them nodding off. Maybe a short power nap during the slow movement is just what they need to be totally inspired by the last movement!

Footnotes

  1. They were asked to complete a survey every hour from 10pm to 5am. Diabolical, no?

Ack! After Countless Hours of Practice...
Why Are Performances Still So Hit or Miss?

It’s not a talent issue. And that rush of adrenaline and emotional roller coaster you experience before performances is totally normal too.

Performing at the upper ranges of your ability under pressure is a unique skill – one that requires specific mental skills, and perhaps a few other tweaks in your approach to practicing too. Elite athletes have been learning these techniques for decades; if nerves and self-doubt have been recurring obstacles in your performances, I’d like to help you do the same.

Click below to learn more about Beyond Practicing – a home-study course where you’ll explore the 6 skills that are characteristic of top performers. And learn how you can develop these into strengths of your own. And begin to see tangible improvements in your playing that transfer to the stage.

Comments

9 Responses

  1. I have never understood why so many use the terms negative and positive emotions. Alle real emotions are positive. Perhaps not pleasant, but positive. It must be very positive to feel fear when someone threatens my life. It is also positive to feel my sorrow when one of my closest died. It is also positive that I get angry if someone violates me or my loved ones. To call some emotions negative allows for me to see a completely wrong internal signal in the direction of having to avoid them and just see them as negative.

    1. Hi Ebbe,

      Interesting perspective; I agree that it’s important to avoid judging emotions as either “good” or “bad”.

      From a research perspective at least, I think “positive” and “negative” are typically used to clarify whether an emotion tends to feel pleasant or unpleasant, which is a little more helpful. In that regard, you may find it interesting to look into some of the studies Yuri Hanin has done on emotions in sport. Along the lines of what you describe, he has looked at the degree to which positive or negative emotions facilitate performance. And for many individuals, emotions that most might think of being “negative,” can actually lead to better performance than some emotions that are typically thought of as being more “positive.”

    2. “It is also positive to feel my sorrow when one of my closest died. It is also positive that I get angry if someone violates me or my loved ones.”

      What I find amazing is how you justify that sorrow after a death and anger after a violation could be “positive” emotion. I’m not a psychoanalyst but I will leave it at as an “interesting” response.

      1. I used to play my pipes at Arlington National Cemetery. I had one job there, and only one job. And that was to get people to go into that place in their souls where they don’t want others to go, and pull their necessary grief to the outside. I’ve seen people break down into liberating tears for the first time in many years. Necessary grief. Liberating tears. A depth of emotion and love they would otherwise never admit dwelt deep inside them. I’ve gone in so exhausted I had no idea how I was going to make it through the service. Terrible cold from the wind off the river. Heat that takes the breath right out of your lungs. Arlington is emotionally hazardous duty. The one thing that keeps us pipers going is that this is the only time many of the families will be there. This is a time when we have to dig down ourselves, because sometimes, we’re the only ones who can give many hearts their voice. It’s not good or bad, positive or negative. It is what it is, and oft times the most difficult ‘performances’ we will ever do in our lives. I often received phone calls from family members who could not remember one single word the ANC rep told them, so it was for me to explain it. The best advice I could give them was that just to ‘be present’. Be in the ‘now’. I think we musicians often lose track that we also must be in ‘the now.’ You can help heal other hearts, but don’t forget yours in the process.

  2. I’m a church musician, and I know I do not play as well when I’m tired and have low energy. I don’t feel engaged with the message of the music, and it seems to not be as well received by the congregation on those days. So the results of this study seems to be a valid conclusion to me. Moral of the story… Get lots of sleep/rest before performances!

  3. This may sound like the strangest question ever, but define ‘sleep-deprived’? What are the parameters of your definition?
    You know me, Noa. ‘Sleep’ means something completely different in my world, and even more so with ‘sleep deprived’. Or do you want me to e-mail this?

    1. Ha, good question. It’s a little tricky to describe, as some participants were more negatively affected by the sleep-sabotaging intervention than others, but we can get some idea from the sleep averages.

      The “sleep-deprived” group got an average of ~287 minutes of sleep (4 hr. 47 min.), while the regular group got ~401 minutes (6 hr. 41 min.).

  4. I have given many speeches to diverse groups of people. In terms of reaction to a speech or performance, I use the 10-80-10 concept:

    10% of the audience hates you. The minute you stand up, step forward, or start talking, they hate you. Hate. They are the ones who will ask questions to try and trip you up, and make heckling comments while you are speaking. Why doesn’t matter. It’s what they are.

    10% of your audience absolutely loves you. Loves that you are there, wants to hear every word. You could read names out of the phone book, and they will cheer and applaud at the end for the superb, inspiring message.

    That leaves the 80% who need to be won over by your presentation. The 10% that loves, you, and the 10% that hates you, don’t matter. It’s the 80% that makes or breaks you. So you have to speak, or play, to their needs and emotions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Get the (Free) Practice Hacks Guide

Learn the #1 thing that top practicers do differently, plus 7 other strategies for practice that sticks.

Discover your mental strengths and weaknesses

If performances have been frustratingly inconsistent, try the 3-min Mental Skills Audit. It won't tell you what Harry Potter character you are, but it will point you in the direction of some new practice methods that could help you level up in the practice room and on stage.

Share216
Tweet
Email